Cook County: Resisting Tyranny is No Longer The People’s Business

Cook County, Illinois, has told the U.S. Supreme Court that resisting tyranny is no longer the people’s business. In its brief defending the county’s ban on AR-15s and similar semiautomatic rifles, the county answers the argument that these rifles are suited for “repelling invasions, suppressing insurrections, and resisting tyranny” with one line: “Today, of course, these responsibilities are reserved for the United States military.”

The justices hear argument December 2 in Viramontes v. Cook County, No. 25-238, consolidated with Grant v. Higgins, No. 25-566, the challenge to Connecticut’s ban. The question is whether the Second and Fourteenth Amendments protect the right to possess AR-15-platform and similar semiautomatic rifles. The October briefs defending the bans show how far the gun-confiscation lobby will go to answer no.

Cook County Writes the Armed Citizen Out of the Constitution

On page 56, the county concedes the history before trying to bury it. It admits the founding generation held “a deep mistrust of standing armies” and that colonists “rightly feared the British soldiers quartered amongst them.” Then, quoting a 1992 law review article, it argues the founders’ design let the nation abandon “revered, but outmoded, military practices.”

Next the county reaches for District of Columbia v. Heller, quoting the Court’s remark that small arms may be no match for “modern-day bombers and tanks.” It skips the point: the very next words in Heller say modern developments “cannot change our interpretation of the right.” From there the county lumps ordinary semiautomatic rifles in with machine guns, hand grenades and rocket launchers as “unusually dangerous weapons.”

Texas Gun Rights Foundation rejects that premise. The Second Amendment secures a right of the people, not a job description the government can reassign to itself. A standing army is the very power an armed citizenry exists to check. Its growth is a reason to guard the right more jealously, not to retire it.

“Cook County just told the Supreme Court that the government’s own army has replaced the people as the guardian of liberty,” said Texas Gun Rights Foundation President Chris McNutt. “That is exactly the argument the Second Amendment was written to defeat. A right that lasts only until the government builds a big enough military is no right at all.”

Connecticut Calls Common Use a “Trivial Counting Exercise”

Connecticut’s corrected brief goes after Heller‘s protection for arms in common use. On page 37, the state dismisses the challengers’ reliance on the “tens of millions of Americans” who own AR-15s, saying nothing supports reading the Constitution through a “trivial counting exercise.” The phrase comes from the Fourth Circuit’s 2024 decision in Bianchi v. Brown, which upheld Maryland’s ban, and Connecticut now asks the Supreme Court to adopt it.

The state goes further, arguing that legislatures have historically banned weapons “only once those weapons became so popular that their dangers to society became obvious and pressing.” Under that logic, the more Americans choose a rifle, the stronger the case for confiscating it. As TXGRF has explained, common use should defeat a ban, not license one.

The Gun-Confiscation Lobby Piles On

On October 28, the Governors Safer Communities Initiative, a coalition of 11 governors from California to Virginia, filed a single brief backing both bans and pointing to “the unique harm posed by assault weapons.”

Global Action on Gun Violence, the group led by Jonathan Lowy, whose Mexico lawsuit against American gunmakers lost 9-0 before this same Court in 2025, went further. Its brief claims Heller “departed from nearly 230 years of precedent,” insists AR-15s are not in common use, and urges the justices to reinstate the means-end balancing that Bruen threw out. That is a request to unwind two decades of Second Amendment law.

The challengers have powerful company of their own. On November 9, the Court granted the Solicitor General’s motion to argue alongside the gun owners on December 2.

Cook County Looks for the Exit

Cook County is also trying to dodge the ruling. After lead petitioner Cutberto Viramontes moved on October 29 to withdraw, the county filed a suggestion of mootness on November 5, arguing that no remaining petitioner has standing and asking the Court to dismiss its case. As of November 15, the Supreme Court docket shows no ruling. In a footnote, the county concedes the maneuver would not stop the justices from deciding the question through the Connecticut case.

What the Ruling Means for Texas

Texas has no statewide ban on AR-15s, but the rule the Court writes here will govern rifle challenges nationwide. Bills already filed for the 2027 session would make it a crime for adults under 21 to buy or possess many semiautomatic rifles. Whether common use is a real constitutional barrier or a “trivial counting exercise” will shape how courts judge restrictions like those.

A ruling that gives governments broad power to ban any arm they label “unusually dangerous” would hand the gun-confiscation lobby a legal weapon for its next push, in Texas and everywhere else. A ruling that enforces common use would put America’s most popular rifle beyond their reach.

Cook County says the people’s responsibility now belongs to the military. The Constitution says the right belongs to the people, and on December 2 Cook County will have to defend its answer in front of the Court.

 

Chris McNutt is president of Texas Gun Rights.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top