Lowy: Americans Don’t Need AR-15s Because They Can Still Buy Handguns

AR-15 competition shooting

Before Bruen, courts generally evaluated firearm restrictions by considering both the burden on individual rights and the government’s reasons for adopting the law. That approach allowed courts to protect gun possession for lawful self-defense while accounting for the actual dangers posed by particular weapons.

GAGV’s brief explains that assault-weapons laws demonstrate why that framework is superior.

The burden imposed by assault weapons restrictions is limited. The laws do not prevent law-abiding people from defending themselves or their homes. Handguns—the firearms most commonly selected for personal protection—remain available for law-abiding people, as do many models of shotguns and rifles.

— Jonathan Lowy in The Fact that Mexican Cartels Buy AR-15s Doesn’t Mean They Should Be Constitutionally Protected.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

8 thoughts on “Lowy: Americans Don’t Need AR-15s Because They Can Still Buy Handguns”

  1. I’m glad that this guy and the rest of the gun control crowd say this stuff in public. I have always believed that they are very comfortable with only the criminal class having guns.

    They are ONLY AGAINST good people having guns. They really are comfortable with the cartels of others. Chopping off heads and other body parts.

    And then hanging them from a bridge. Or throwing them into a dance club onto the dance floor.

    “Liberal fascism” is very real. Now go read the book.

  2. “Before Bruen, courts generally evaluated firearm restrictions by considering both the burden on individual rights and the government’s reasons for adopting the law. That approach allowed courts to protect gun possession for lawful self-defense while accounting for the actual dangers posed by particular weapons.”

    This is deceptively disingenuous and its dishonest.

    This was ‘interest balancing’ and it never allowed “courts to protect gun possession for lawful self-defense while accounting for the actual dangers posed by particular weapons.”.

    ‘interest balancing’ was a created ad hoc legal strategy used by courts as a balancing test to decide a legal case by weighing a person’s constitutional rights against the government’s interest (no where in the constitution does it give government an ‘interest’ to be decided vs the right of the individual in relation to a constitutional right). It originated based upon the ‘reasonableness’ requirement of the 4th Amendment. Inevitability the government would win the case, because the court would substitute assumptions and vague generalities, even sneak in their own political allegiance leanings, to define the right as either not, or less than, an individual right the government had ‘some interest of’ power to control for some reason. Its kinda involved, but basically there were two steps – the first was if the law or action of government implicated the Second amendment. Its at this step the courts would often define their own view by substituting assumptions and vague generalities, even sneak in their own political allegiance leanings, creating a mishmash cipher which had the effect of them basically going (to the plaintiff) “its not your right, we control it and its how we say it is’ – then it was on to the step two ‘scrutiny format’ and this is where the government inevitability won 98% of the time by supporting the courts ‘now defined’ view with their arguments, which the plaintiff had no hope to overcome because they were arguing the facts and were confined to the right as the court defined it and the government was basically arguing the courts already made up opinion. In other words, ‘interest balancing’ was about giving the government power it does not constitutionally have – the power to control the exercise of a constitutional right. This made a 2A case extremely difficult for a plaintiff to win, under ‘interest balancing’ the odds were stacked against them before the first argument was made.

    The U.S. Constitution grants the federal government only those powers specifically listed in the document, while the Bill of Rights explicitly limits government power to protect individual liberties such as that of the Second Amendment and not control the exercise of them.

    No where in the constitution does it give government the power to control the exercise of a constitutional right. Its a self-created power that was created by government and allowed to exist and set precedent by the courts use of ‘interest balancing’.

    The founders made this known, that government was not to have power over the legitimate exercise of a constitutional right.

    No where in the constitution does it say the second amendment right exercise or the terms ‘bear’ or ‘arms’ is decided based upon “actual dangers posed by particular weapons”, no where in the constitution does it say a constitutional right exercise is decided by something that might happen. This was another fake thing the courts and anti-gun interests interjected.

  3. I really hope SCOTUS kills AWBs.
    Gun control is the only issue I’ve ever really cared about and it’s the only reason I follow politics or bother to vote at all.

    1. As I have written earlier, most SCOTUS watchers are confident that they will.

      Thomas and Alito are not fools. Even when they had 2 other votes to grant cert petitions in 2A cases post-Heller/MacDonald while Anthony Kennedy was on the Court, the deliberately did not do so because Kennedy’s squishiness meant that they could not be sure they could “get to five” if the Court took a case, and if they could not there was a good chance that the Court would unwind or restrict Heller. The other side had the same problem: they did not want to grant cert either, because they could not be sure that Kennedy (who voted with the majority in Heller and MacDonald) would not vote against them and thus affirm / expand Heller. That’s why we had a frustrating period of years where SCOTUS didn’t take any significant 2A cases, even where lower courts were plainly thumbing their nose at Heller.

      That the justices engage in this kind of internal nose-counting is both common sense and well documented. Political scientists use data metrics/analysis (e.g., Guttman scaling) to predict this, but of course the justices know better than anyone what their colleagues are really thinking.)

      This political reality explains why SCOTUS hasn’t taken up an AWB case before, even though it is pretty clear that Thomas, Alito, Gorsuch, and Kavanaugh would vote to nuke AWB’s. The reason was that ACB was perceived as having gone squishy (and of course Roberts defines that term), and thus they did not want to take a case that might result in Bruen being revisited. But in the last two 2A cases, ACB has returned to her roots and has been fully onboard with the Bruen framework. Remember also that the justices are in constant communication with each other, especially informally.

      Thus, most seasoned court watchers believe that the cert grant in the two AWB cases came only after the Thomas 2A block were confident that ACB would ride with them and not deviate from the Bruen test. (They know better than to trust Roberts, whose behavior in the Obamacare case proved that he is compromised and/or just cowardly.) And if ACB is on side, AWB’s are doomed, as there is no way they survive scrutiny under the Bruen test.

      That’s why we are seeing amicus and other briefs in favor of AWB’s like Lewy’s that do not even attempt to justify those laws under the Bruen framework, but instead rely on arguments that would require the Court to revisit and dismantle the Bruen test. And I trust Clarence Thomas to have made sure that was very, very, very unlikely to happen before voting to grant cert.

      1. “This political reality explains why SCOTUS hasn’t taken up an AWB case before, even though it is pretty clear that Thomas, Alito, Gorsuch, and Kavanaugh would vote to nuke AWB’s.”

        LKB – Since a semi-auto cannot function as a semi-auto without a magazine of some sort, is it possible the SCotUS will include magazine capacity bans in their upcoming ruling, especially considering they well might consider now packing the bench with their stooges? They have the Senate votes now to confirm who they want…

        1. No. The scope of the opinion is going to be limited by the questions on which cert was granted, and mag capacity isn’t there.

          Now, the *reasoning* of the opinion might make mag limits a dead letter, but those would still have to be fought case by case, especially in places like NY and CA, where the courts are wiling to openly defy SCOTUS on 2A issues.

  4. If this is the best that the other side can come up with, expect a 6-3 reversal that nukes AWB’s.

    SCOTUS explicitly rejected his argument in Heller, where DC argued that its handgun prohibition was OK because people could still have rifles and shotguns. And end/means scrutiny (which now has been repeatedly rejected by SCOTUS in the 2A context) is nothing but an excuse to return the Second Amendment to a constitutional right in name only.

  5. You don’t need a car because you can still buy a bicycle.
    You don’t need a bicycle because you have feet.
    Now, lets talk about if you need your feet.

    so goes the communist logic.

Scroll to Top